I recently attempted an install of an Electron based device at a remote park in NC. According to the AT&T Coverage map, there is nothing there.
But, the Ranger uses Verizon had coverage and the Verizon coverage map claims coverage.
So, could I use an Electron LTE on Verizon to make this work? What would be required?
Thanks,
Chip
I use both Verizon and AT&T on the Boron LTE and an external SIM. I currently use Hologram.io and have been happy so far, though I won’t be putting them out into the field until the end of the month. My previous prototypes used ThingsMobile, and while they’re cheap I did not have good experience there (specifically, connecting to Verizon was a problem.)
I use CONNECTION_MODE(MANUAL) and the following code in setup().
Cellular.on();
sendCommand("AT+URAT=7", 60000);
sendCommand("AT+UMNOPROF=0", 60000);
sendCommand("AT+CFUN=1", 60000);
sendCommand uses Cellular.command() to send the AT commands and a callback prints the results to the logger.
First, glad to hear that you are able to use both services. I am intrigued by Hologram if they can deliver Verizon coverage (assume that means that Particle cannot?).
However, in searching the Hologram community site and help section, I did not see anything about Electron LTE (which has an eSIM) setup. Were you able to get the Electron LTE setup?
Thanks, Chip
Particle only supports AT&T in the US currently. I have the same issue with AT&T coverage in rural areas that you do. It’s spotty at best. By Electron LTE, do you mean the E series? If so, it can’t be used with a third party SIM, so you won’t be able to get it on Verizon unless Particle adds them as a carrier (which I’ve been asking them to do!). Same with the B series.
The options I see are Electron 2G/3G or Boron LTE. The Boron works great with your carrier board, so maybe that’s an option?
I was hoping for the Electron LTE since it would be consistent hardware. That said, the Boron LTE is an option - I just need to finish the carrier board with the Real Time Clock in order to get low power.
So, you can use the Hologram “eSIM” with the Boron LTE to get Verizon coverage?
Thanks, Chip
No, not without modifying the Boron. The SIM pins aren’t exposed. You can use a standard (nano) SIM though. They also sell a more ruggedized SIM.
@all, I wanted to share my experiences with setting up a Hologram SIM with the Boron and my attempt to get access to Verizon LTE on the Particle Boron.
First, let me say that this is a cautionary tale and that, at this time, you cannot get a Verizon LTE SIM to work on a Boron. Particle does not have carrier certification from Verizon and therefore Verizon will block a Particle device detected on their network as the IMEI numbers have not been added to their “white list”. What is more, Hologram will pre-empt this situation by blocking Verizon access.
Here is what I learned from how to set up a 3rd Party SIM.
There is good documentation of this process from Particle - it will get you +80% of the way there. Make sure you take the time to read the full document. BTW, if you are using a 3rd Party SIM, Particle sees no monthly revenue from that device so it is great that they are doing this much for the benefit of their users.
The process above will likely - in my experience - leave your device in a non-functional “listening mode” state. This is because the Boron has not received the signal that set up is complete. If this happens to you (after you follow the steps in #1 above) flash this sketch from @rickkas7 and then reflash Tinker:
#include "Particle.h"
#include "dct.h"
SYSTEM_MODE(SEMI_AUTOMATIC);
void setup() {
// This clears the setup done flag on brand new devices so it won't stay in listening mode
const uint8_t val = 0x01;
dct_write_app_data(&val, DCT_SETUP_DONE_OFFSET, 1);
// This is just so you know the operation is complete
pinMode(D7, OUTPUT);
digitalWrite(D7, HIGH);
}
void loop() {
}
/*
* Project Hologram-TestCode
* Description: Adapted from Particle docs for Hologram
* Author: Chip McClelland - and many others
* Date:1-25-20
*/
//Boron LTE SIM, Credendtial, and Network settings.
#include "Particle.h"
#include "dct.h"
SYSTEM_MODE(SEMI_AUTOMATIC);
void setup() {
// Code to mark setup as complete in case you have the blue flashing LED - comment out section below once done.
// 0x01 = setup done
// 0xff = setup not done (go into listening mode at boot)
// const uint8_t val = 0x01;
// dct_write_app_data(&val, DCT_SETUP_DONE_OFFSET, 1);
// End section to mark setup complete
//For external Hologram (or other) SIM, uncomment the following and use the appropriate APN credentials:
Cellular.setActiveSim(EXTERNAL_SIM);
Cellular.setCredentials("hologram");
//For internal (Particle) SIM, uncomment the following:
// Cellular.setActiveSim(INTERNAL_SIM);
// Cellular.clearCredentials();
// Mobile Network Operator (MNO) configuration:
//* 0 (default value): SW default
//* 1: SIM ICCID select
//* 2: ATT
//* 3: Verizon
//* 4: Telstra
//* 5: TMO
//* 6: CT
int mnoProf = 2;
Cellular.on();
Mesh.off();
Cellular.command("AT+COPS=2\r\n"); // De-register from network.
Cellular.command("AT+UMNOPROF=%d\r\n", mnoProf); // Explicitly call MNO profile from list above.
Cellular.command("AT+CFUN=15\r\n"); // Reset the modem.
// This is just so you know the operation is complete (turns on onboard blue LED).
pinMode(D7, OUTPUT);
digitalWrite(D7, HIGH);
}
void loop() {
}
Hologram has a somewhat outdated guide for the Electron which is mildly useful.
There is an issue which may arise after a number of failed connection attempts. Basically, the SIM card builds a “black list” of sites that have failed to connect and they will not be contacted in future attempts. This can become an issue and there is a guide from Hologram to address this - you will need to build these commands into a sketch. Flash the code and then reflash with Tinker.
I hope that bringing all this together in one place is helpful to anyone who wants to use a 3rd party SIM. Please let me know if I got anything wrong here as I am only a novice at this.
However, let me close with this. The first and best path for most users is to use the Particle SIM. If you want access to Verizon - don’t waste your time. If you live in a country where you have no choice, I hope this helps but also please let Particle know of your needs as I know their intent is to make 3rd Party SIM usage unnecessary.
Thanks, Chip
You may run into problems with Verizon. With LTE Cat M1, some carriers (including AT&T and Verizon in the United States), require manufacturers to certify their devices with the carrier. When this process is complete, the manufacturer then uploads the IMEIs of their devices to the carrier. Particle does this for AT&T. (The IMEI is the identifier associated with the modem, as compared to the ICCID, which is associated with the SIM card.)
However, since the Particle SIM does not support Verizon, we do not certify with Verizon and do not upload the IMEIs. Thus Boron LTE using a Verizon-compatible SIM are prone to being banned from the Verizon network. Often there is a grace period before you get banned, so it may work for a while. But be aware that Verizon could decide to ban you at any time for using a non-certified IMEI.
Thanks Rick, that explains why my Boron with Hologram sim connected to Verizon’s network few months ago but I was never able to get it online again since then. It works flawlessly wit AT&T though, using the AT+UMNOPROF=2 command you described before.
Is including native support on Verizon the the Particle Roadmap? If I recall back during Spectra 2020, the question was asked in one of the chat/break out rooms to Particle, the response from a Particle rep in the chat was likely adding Version support in Q4 2020. Maybe I was just dreaming but is this being developed by Particle for dual support between Version and/or AT&T? Could someone shed some light on if this is on the Particle Road Map? Thanks!
Verizon support in the United States has not been ruled out, nor confirmed as a definite product. However, if there is support it may be a different SKU, as we will probably not be able to enable Verizon with the existing Particle SIM. Since Verizon requires device certification and registration of each device’s IMEI, this means that it’s unlikely that the Boron LTE will ever work on Verizon, even with a 3rd-party SIM card.
Alright… Thank you for clarifying. I had 1-2 devices in a specific area that did not have the best reception. I was tempted to try a 3G Boron instead of LTE or if it had Verison I would try that as well. My work around for now is to put the Boron LTE in the high spot on the property with the best cellular signal strength and then use LoRa to reach the areas of interest. It should work well but just additional hardware/multiple devices. Knowing this helps me understand this further and what action I should take. Thanks!